Fish Tacos vs Shrimp Tacos: Which Should You Order in Collingwood?

Trying to choose between fish tacos or shrimp tacos in Collingwood? Enjoy fresh flavours, house toppings, and fresh-cut fries at Harbour Street Fish Bar, plus live events in a relaxed setting.

Tacos might not be the first thing you think of when you’re planning dinner in Collingwood — but they’ve become a go-to for guests looking for something flavourful, relaxed, and easy to enjoy.

At Harbour Street Fish Bar, both Fish Tacos and Shrimp Tacos bring something different to the table. If you’re deciding between the two, here’s what sets them apart.

The Fish Tacos — Crisp and Classic

If you lean toward something familiar and satisfying, the Fish Tacos are the safe bet — in the best way.

Served in your choice of hard or soft shell, they’re layered with guacamole, tomato, coleslaw, pickled onions, cheese, and chipotle mayo. The combination balances crunch, creaminess, and just enough heat.

They’re substantial enough to feel like a full dinner but still light enough to keep things relaxed. For guests who already love fish & chips, this is a natural extension in taco form.

The Shrimp Tacos — Bright and Tropical

If you’re in the mood for something more layered and vibrant, the Shrimp Tacos bring a little extra personality.

Tiger shrimp are paired with guacamole, piña colada coleslaw, pickled onion, mango and papaya salsa, and served with fresh-cut fries.

There’s sweetness, acidity, and brightness throughout, which makes this option feel lighter and more flavour-forward. It’s especially popular with guests who want something that stands out without feeling heavy.

Hard Shell or Soft Shell?

Both taco options are available in hard or soft shell, which gives you some flexibility depending on your texture preference.

  • Hard shell gives you that satisfying crunch.
  • Soft shell keeps things a little more cohesive and easier to eat.

Either way, you’re getting fresh-cut fries on the side — because tacos should still feel like a proper dinner.

A Reliable Casual Dinner Option

Tacos tend to fit naturally into relaxed evenings. They’re easy to share if you’re ordering multiple dishes, but they’re also balanced enough to stand on their own.

For locals, they’re a dependable midweek option. For visitors, they offer something slightly different from the typical seafood plate while still staying true to the menu’s strengths.

Whether you’re stopping in before live music or settling in for a laid-back dinner, tacos make it easy.

The Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?

  • If you want something crisp, classic, and seafood-forward → Fish Tacos.
  • If you want something bright, layered, and a little unexpected → Shrimp Tacos.

There isn’t a wrong answer — just a different flavour direction depending on your mood.

Looking for Tacos in Collingwood?

If tacos are calling your name, both options deliver flavour without overcomplicating things. Take a look at the full menu and decide which one fits your night.

For Takeout & Special Inquiries

No reservations. For special events and private bookings please contact us.

Scroll to Top